Years 9–10 · Stage 5 Advanced Path

When a maths question goes wrong

Keep every solution, then use the context to decide which ones make sense.

A neat line of working can still lose an answer. Before dividing by an expression containing x, ask whether it could equal zero.

The shortcut that loses zero

From x² = 5x, dividing by x gives x = 5. But x = 0 also works. The division silently assumes x is not zero.

Instead, move everything to one side: x² − 5x = 0. Factorise to get x(x − 5) = 0. A product is zero when at least one factor is zero, so x = 0 or x = 5.

Worked example · Original practice question

Turn an area into an equation

A rectangle has width x metres, length (x + 5) metres and area 84 m². Find its dimensions.

See the worked solution
  1. Write the area equation: x(x + 5) = 84.
  2. Expand and rearrange: x² + 5x − 84 = 0.
  3. Find two numbers with product −84 and sum 5: 12 and −7.
  4. Factorise: (x + 12)(x − 7) = 0, so x = −12 or x = 7.
  5. A physical width must be positive. Keep x = 7, giving length 12 m.
  6. Check: 7 × 12 = 84 m².

The rectangle is 7 m by 12 m. Reject −12 because of this context, not because negative solutions are always wrong.

Your turn · Original practice question

Keep both answers this time

Solve x² = 4x + 21. Explain why both solutions are valid.

Check your answer
  1. x² − 4x − 21 = 0.
  2. (x − 7)(x + 3) = 0.
  3. x = 7 or x = −3. Substitution gives 49 = 49 and 9 = 9.

Both are valid: the question places no physical or domain restriction on x.

Syllabus references

Checked 11 October 2026. These are original Akari practice materials, not NESA examination questions or complete course summaries. Follow your school’s topic sequence.

Explore maths tutoringBack to all study notes