Year 11 · Mathematics Standard

Which plan is actually cheaper?

Compare two linear models, find a break-even point and work within a budget.

The smaller starting fee doesn’t always mean the smaller total. Separate the fixed charge from the amount that changes.

Read the model before solving it

In C = b + md, b is a fixed charge and m is the cost per day. The gradient tells you how quickly the cost grows.

These are fictional equipment-hire plans. Assume whole days, a non-refundable initial fee, and no discounts or extra charges.

Worked example · Original practice question

One decision, three calculations

Plans A and B cost A = 48 + 2.40d and B = 24 + 3.60d dollars for d whole days. Find the break-even point, the cheaper plan for 35 days, and the maximum days affordable with $180 under each plan.

See the worked solution
  1. Equal costs: 48 + 2.4d = 24 + 3.6d. Hence 24 = 1.2d, so d = 20 days.
  2. At 20 days both cost $96. Below 20 days B is cheaper; above 20 days A is cheaper.
  3. At 35 days: A = 48 + 2.4 × 35 = $132. B = 24 + 3.6 × 35 = $150.
  4. Budget with A: (180 − 48) ÷ 2.4 = 55, so 55 days.
  5. Budget with B: (180 − 24) ÷ 3.6 = 43⅓, so only 43 whole days.

Plan A saves $18 over 35 days. A budget answer must respect the domain: 43⅓ days cannot be rounded up to 44 when only whole days are sold.

Your turn · Original practice question

Does a third plan ever win?

Plan C costs C = 36 + 3d. When do all three plans match? Is C ever cheaper than both A and B?

Check your answer
  1. At d = 20, all three cost $96.
  2. C − B = 12 − 0.6d, which is positive for d < 20.
  3. C − A = −12 + 0.6d, which is positive for d > 20.

C never beats both. B is cheaper before 20 days; A is cheaper after 20 days.

Syllabus references

Checked 11 October 2026. These are original Akari practice materials, not NESA examination questions or complete course summaries. Follow your school’s topic sequence.

Explore maths tutoringBack to all study notes